I found a possibility to retrieve all the votes under any post (including per-site meta), like they would appear in a reputation tab, with a difference: not separated by days (i.e. all the days in one list)
No idea if this would be useful anywhere, so I'm not going to use it anyhow
Screenshot below from stats of my per-site metal question https://meta.stackoverflow.com/questions/287252/let-the-upvotes-be-green
Funny thing: since per-site metas don't actually have any visible reputation, we can see that the old votes were never recalculated and result in +5 instead of modern +10