Sonic's Den

Sonic the Anonymous Hedgehog

6:27 AM

Poke

user312109

here

Sonic the Anonymous Hedgehog

in Shadow's Den, 1 min ago, by Muze

here and I don't know how to isolate those particular mod messages out of the inbox?

user312109

i would have to go through 1000s

user312109

the first 3 times where over 1 year ago

user312109

1 day week 6months

Sonic the Anonymous Hedgehog

6:30 AM

@Muze Then page through to about one year ago

user312109

ok be a min

Sonic the Anonymous Hedgehog

They are categorized as "moderator message", so if you Ctrl+F and search for that

user312109

1st time was in physic se says 404 page not found:( looking

user312109

Moderator Private Message
from moderators
sent Mar 14 '16 at 21:45
to
Muze

Hello,

I'm writing in reference to your Engineering Stack Exchange account:

http://engineering.stackexchange.com/users/4255/jen

We've noticed that you've asked many questions, a large number of which were not well received by other members of our community.

Specifically, all of your questions have been downvoted and closed because they seemed to be hastily written, or of the type that we'd prefer users refrain from asking. This is a troubling pattern; we'd like to make sure that you've read the help that we have…

user312109

I have come along way in writing a good question

user312109

6:37 AM

serching

user312109

Hello,

I'm writing in reference to your Engineering Stack Exchange account:

http://engineering.stackexchange.com/users/4255/jen

We've noticed that you've asked many questions, a large number of which were not well received by other members of our community.

Specifically, many of your questions were downvoted and closed because they seemed to be hastily written, or of the type that we'd prefer users refrain from asking. This is a troubling pattern; we'd like to make sure that you've read the help that we have available for asking questions. Please take some time to read all of the inform…

user312109

Asking to many low quality questions.

user312109

from moderators
sent Sep 17 '16 at 19:33
to
Muze

I don't believe there is much that can be done to refine the questions you asked this month. The challenge with those questions is that they dwell more in the land of hypothetical as opposed to a specific, actual challenge.

Engineering StackExchange questions that do well tend to be grounded in real, practical problems. The site doesn't exist for discussions built around overarching questions that might better belong in a science fiction novel.

Sonic the Anonymous Hedgehog

@Muze This is already included in the message you sent above.

user312109

They are identical but have different suspension periods

Sonic the Anonymous Hedgehog

6:47 AM

@Muze Right, 7 and 30 days. Where's the message for the third suspension?

user312109

looking

user312109

as you see same person

user312109

vague

user312109

Same thing I'm sure

user312109

Moderator Private Message
from moderators
sent Jul 1 '17 at 10:28
to
Muze

Hello,

I'm writing in reference to your Electrical Engineering Stack Exchange account:

https://electronics.stackexchange.com/users/103579/muze

We've noticed that you've asked many questions, a large number of which were not well received by other members of our community.

Specifically, many of your questions were downvoted and closed because they seemed to be hastily written, or of the type that we'd prefer users refrain from asking. This is a troubling pattern; we'd like to make sure that you've read the help th…

user312109

6:50 AM

there is no warning if you ask to many question before suspension

user312109

looking

user312109

3rd one
Moderator Private Message
from moderators
sent Oct 9 '17 at 1:26
to
Muze

Hello,

I'm writing in reference to your Engineering Stack Exchange account:

https://engineering.stackexchange.com/users/4139/muze

We've noticed that you've asked many questions, a large number of which were not well received by other members of our community.

Specifically, many of your questions were downvoted and closed because they seemed to be hastily written, or of the type that we'd prefer users refrain from asking. This is a troubling pattern; we'd like to make sure that you've read the help that we …

user312109

they all read like that. I remember coming off suspension once and asked a question and got suspended for a down vote.

user312109

I tryrd to fix those questions after months only that it gets rolled back. I never had time to fix them before they was locked because of the suspensions.

user312109

This time I got suspended for improving on them.

user312109

6:57 AM

not invalidating answers

user312109

same with electrical se

Sonic the Anonymous Hedgehog

@Muze Right, so your last mod message summarizes the overall issue perfectly. You already have a negative track record with regard to asking questions because of your prior behavior.

@Muze Thanks for showing me those moderator messages. Now, I want you to go through each of your questions where you were accused of "invalidating answers", go through each answer, and explain to me how each answer still answers the newly edited form of the question. Understand?

user312109

what does that mean. My bad question have to stay bad because they have good answers

user312109

?

user312109

i did that.

user312109

7:01 AM

I understand about invalidation but it did,t invalidate

Sonic the Anonymous Hedgehog

@Muze You edited questions and were accused of invalidating existing answers. I want you to go through each answer to each question where you were accused of invalidating answers by editing, and explain to me how each answer still answers the edited form of the question (prior to rollback).

@Muze If that claim is true, it will be evident once you've gone and done that.

user312109

Yes I double checked

user312109

the revised question was way better

user312109

you can roll it back and see

user312109

-2

Q: What are the main problems with lightning being a renewable energy source?

I viewed many engines that are powered by electricity? The problem is driving that much current through transformers and even the wire. The levitron little spinning magnet is suspended by a magnet. Could a huge levetron be hard wired capture lightning from power poles through a huge coil large ...

Sonic the Anonymous Hedgehog

7:05 AM

@Muze Let me make myself clear. You asked a (bad) question, then you got some answers. You edited it to "improve" it, as you say. Then those "improvements" were rolled back, and you were accused of "invalidating" those answers. I want you to go through each answer to each question where you were accused of doing this, and explain to me how it's still a valid answer to the "improved" form of the question.

user312109

It was an improvement maybe if I got permission from each answerer if I could revise it first?

Sonic the Anonymous Hedgehog

@Muze To be frank, many users would lose patience here. You don't seem to be doing what you are asked.

user312109

it just this one

user312109

i am trying

user312109

well now I know I was suspended for asking to many bad questions. Thank you.

Sonic the Anonymous Hedgehog

7:09 AM

@Muze If you don't want to discuss this further, and just wait out the suspension, so be it.

user312109

and again for making them better. I do but its late. They were bad and I didn't get a chance really to fix them this or last time.

user312109

no other se suspended me for editing my questions just roll back.

Sonic the Anonymous Hedgehog

@Muze If you can't explain to me why the current answers to the question you linked above answer this question, your suspension is completely warranted.

user312109

roll back not suspension. is it not the same question same physics just better eritten?

Sonic the Anonymous Hedgehog

@Muze I can't make sense of how the current answers to that question answer that revision to that question.

So I asked you for an explanation of how they do actually make sense, because I may have missed something. But you didn't do that.

So I suggest you wait out your suspension. If anything, wait 6 months, then contact SE clearly stating that you perfectly understand what you were suspended for, that you won't repeat the same behavior again, and will ask new useful questions (and not edit existing ones so the answers don't answer the improved versions anymore). This might persuade them to reduce the block to time served, but it's a long shot.

user312109

7:18 AM

I see what you mean but still. I didn't change it to invalidate to question. It is not a closed question. How am I supposed to fix it.

user312109

answer

Sonic the Anonymous Hedgehog

@Muze Show me with evidence why that claim is true.

user312109

should have been rolled back a given to opportunity to fix it. and I can't

Sonic the Anonymous Hedgehog

@Muze Complaining about how your suspension is "unfair" goes nowhere. Want anything to go anywhere? Provide evidence.

user312109

It is evedent that the suspension period are way to long for minor infractions. 1 year for invalidating a question on accident.

Sonic the Anonymous Hedgehog

7:22 AM

1 min ago, by Sonic the Anonymous Hedgehog

@Muze Complaining about how your suspension is "unfair" goes nowhere. Want anything to go anywhere? Provide evidence.

If you don't come back to me with evidence, I won't discuss this further.

Transcript for