Reopening is hard. It requires thinking, which is also hard. Fortunately, I have done some of the hard thinking for you, and made a handy flow-chart for your benefit:
Should I re-open a closed question?
Note that this also doubles as a handy Stack Exchange drinking game.
@Shog9, Thanks for answer. But my question is can I reopen based on the stated reasons? What if I don't follow the flow chart and vote reopen just because of the specified reasons in my question?
That really depends on how far you deviate, @BVR. If, for instance, you replace "Go have a beer" with "post lots of spam" then that would tend to change the outcome considerably.
@Shog9, I am against closing a question without proper rationale or proper reason. I believe Close voters also think hard to close question and should be able to explain the rationale behind close vote.
@BVR Are you re-opening because you can't see a reason for the question to be closed?
That's great.
If you recognize that the question should be closed, but you're voting to re-open anyway because the voters didn't fill out the paperwork to your satisfaction... that's kind of a waste of time.
@shog9, I would like to reopen the question for the following reasons
-I feel Question is genuine and not crap. - Close voters doesn’t provide valid rationale to close the vote even if requested. And I am not convinced with their reason
