« first day (18 days earlier)      last day (2084 days later) » 

Martin
Martin
8:21 AM
Maybe I should ask this on Meta.SE, but I'll try here first. (It's more out of curiosity than something really useful.)
I have noticed that even users below 10k can see (some part of) deleted post if they find reopen or suggested edit review - here are examples I happen to have at hand: mathoverflow.net/review/reopen/96268 and mathoverflow.net/review/suggested-edits/95740
Are some data on reviews of deleted posts still available in the SEDE database, or when a post is removed, the data about reviews are lost, too?
10
Q: Can the reviewtasks table include the reviews for deleted posts as well?

reneThe table reviewtasks is sanitized for deleted posts. This means that it is hard, if not impossible, for the users that care and for those that want to evaluate the effectiveness of a community to find reliable statistics from SEDE on completed reviewtasks. If the data was available it would ma...

feature-request data-explorer
So I guess that the answer to my question is that results of reviews of the posts that are now deleted are no longer available in SEDE.
 
 
1 hour later…
rene
rene
9:51 AM
@Martin they are pretty strict on what is deleted needs to stay deleted for anyone not > 10K
 
Martin
Martin
Hm... in that case, should the fact that I can see part of deleted posts in the review (if I happen to have a link - as in the examples above) considered a bug?
That's visible also to unregistered users.
 
rene
rene
That is more a corner case I guess, or by design if you wish
I would have to check if that unregisterd users scenario also goes for spam/rude posts
 
Martin
Martin
I'm fine with that interpretation. At least one trick to see a part of deleted posts. (Although probably quite cumbersome.)
 
rene
rene
yeah, and only those that get reviewed and/or selected for an audit
@Martin this is an LQ audit on SO: stackoverflow.com/review/low-quality-posts/20495889 where I can't see the answer when not logged in
 
Martin
Martin
@rene I think it only works for suggested edit and reopen. (At least only for those types of reviews I was able to see something on a site where I am below 10k.)
As an example - this is the same post, I do not see anything in LQP review, but I see it in suggest edit review: mathoverflow.net/review/low-quality-posts/93966 and mathoverflow.net/review/suggested-edits/93968
 
rene
rene
10:02 AM
@Martin this is relevant in that context: meta.stackexchange.com/questions/306875/…
@Martin yeah, got it.
 
Martin
Martin
Glorfindel, who else: Restrict the access to suggested edit reviews on deleted posts. So I was not the first person to notice this. :-)
 
rene
rene
yeah, in the spam fighting context lots of things you took for granted turns out to be a problem
 
Martin
Martin
Hm, I don't think something like that would really help the spammer too much. Not many people will see that, and it is unlikely to get crawled by a search engine.
 
rene
rene
I believe a spammer gets paid if they prove their spam is visible. At least that was some of the rationale to close down these routes
 

« first day (18 days earlier)      last day (2084 days later) »